Storm Chasers vs. Local Contractors: What Every Homeowner Should Know

Three weeks ago, a powerful hailstorm swept through Evansville, Wisconsin, leaving behind a trail of damaged roofs, battered siding, and anxious homeowners. In the days following, many residents found themselves bombarded with roofing contractors—some knocking on doors within hours. While it's normal for contractors to respond to storm damage, it's critical to understand the difference between storm chasers and trusted local professionals before signing any contracts.

At DMR Exteriors, we're proud to be a locally owned and operated company based in nearby Janesville. We’ve seen the damage firsthand, and we're here to help our neighbors rebuild safely and with peace of mind. But first, let’s break down what you need to know about storm chasers, how they operate, and why working with a local contractor matters more than ever.

What Is a Storm Chaser?

Storm chasers are out-of-town contractors who follow severe weather events across the country, quickly moving into affected areas to capitalize on the sudden demand for roof and exterior repairs. They typically go door-to-door, offering “free inspections,” promising quick fixes, and pushing homeowners to sign contracts immediately.

While not all storm chasers are inherently dishonest, many prioritize volume over quality, rely on high-pressure sales tactics, and leave the area as soon as the work—or your check—clears.

Common Tactics to Watch For:

• Offering to waive your insurance deductible (this is insurance fraud)
• Asking you to sign a contingency contract without fully explaining it
• Promising ultra-fast turnaround times with little or no inspection
• Lack of local references or proper Wisconsin licensing
• Out-of-state license plates or temporary office addresses

Why Choosing a Local Contractor Like DMR Exteriors Matters

Local contractors are invested in your community, not just your insurance payout. At DMR Exteriors, we’ve built our business by serving Janesville, Evansville, and surrounding Rock County communities with honesty, craftsmanship, and long-term accountability.

Here’s What Sets Local Roofers Apart:

• We’re here before, during, and after the storm. If something goes wrong months later, you can reach us—because we’re just down the road.
• We understand local codes and permitting requirements, ensuring your project is 100% compliant with city and county regulations.
• We work closely with local insurance adjusters, making your claims process smoother and more accurate.
• We rely on our reputation. Our name is known in the community, and our reviews reflect the quality and integrity we bring to every job.

How to Vet a Roofer After a Hailstorm

Whether you’ve already been approached or are just beginning the process, here are a few critical steps to follow before choosing a contractor:

1. Check credentials: Ask for their Wisconsin contractor license, insurance certificates, and a physical local address.
2. Read reviews: Look at Google, Facebook, and Better Business Bureau listings. Pay attention to whether reviewers mention local experience.
3. Get multiple quotes: Don’t fall for high-pressure tactics. Get at least two or three written estimates before committing.
4. Ask for local references: A good contractor can show you recent work in your neighborhood.
5. Don’t sign anything under pressure: If a contractor is rushing you to sign, walk away.

We're Not Just a Contractor—We’re Your Neighbor

At DMR Exteriors, we don’t chase storms—we answer the call when our community needs us. Our team is made up of local professionals who live and work in Southern Wisconsin, and we treat every project like it’s happening on our own block.

If your home in Evansville was hit in the recent storm, we invite you to contact us for a free, no-obligation inspection. We’ll walk you through the damage, help you understand the insurance process, and provide a clear, honest quote for the repairs your home needs.

Don’t let storm chasers take advantage of your situation.
Choose local. Choose trusted. Choose DMR Exteriors.